News:

Harry Potter Fan - 100% has been online for 20 years
Please help support this site by visiting our partners www.forbiddenplanet.com for lots of cool Harry Potter Merch!
CLICK HERE!
A small percentage of each sale goes towards the upkeep of the site.

Main Menu

Another Mistake!

Started by 0612, November 28, 2005, 12:46:37 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0612

You need to meet the following criteria to understand the contents of this post:
1) You have read HP:PoA (Book)
2) You have watched HP:PoA (Movie)
3) You have read HP:HBP

As you remember in the third book (I'm talking about the book now, not the movie), you'd remember Hermione slapped Malfoy.
In the third movie (Movie and not book this time), Hermione punched Malfoy.

In HP:HBP, JK Rowling made a mistake by saying Hermione punched Malfoy, when in fact in her original script says slapped.
Just thought posting it here would be a laugh. ;D

Ginny Weasly

You know, I was reading the sixth book again and saw that part. I was pretty sure she had slapped him, but I wasn't positive. Lolz.
My motivation
An oath I've sworn to defend


My dedication
To all that I've sworn to protect
I carry out my orders
With not a regret

0612

LOL... JK gets influenced by her own movies... But oh well, we're all human and we all make mistakes :P, what more, I would have preferred Hermione to punch rather than slap ;D :P

LavyBrown

I would have liked to see Hermione slap Malfoy in the movie but it was a really good punch
Don't do it behind the garden gate, love is blind but the neighbours ain't!
Can I get your picture? I collect nature disasters.
Whoever said nothing's impossible never tried to slam a revolving door.
I must confess, I was born at a very early age

pig

 lol i nether noticed that yeah it was a good punch

0612

Yeah... Notice that, when Hermione punches his face, his entire head bounces off the rock behind him... cool

jon weasley

i never really thought about it before but youre right
7  1/2 days till the deathly hallows!!!!!!!!!!!!

0612

Thanks... LOLZ, it was a real coincidence, ya know... I opened Book 3 at a random page and 'witnessed' Hermione's slap, then I felt bored and swapped for book 6 and opened it at a random page and spotted the mistake! LOLZ...

mamabiscuit

lolz that is really funny
J K Rowling IS THE BEST! J K ROWLING IS THE BEST!

mamabiscuit

J K Rowling IS THE BEST! J K ROWLING IS THE BEST!