James Potter: alive and well(ish)!!!!!!!

[IHeartHP101]

I think that James Potter is alive:

-James and Lupin switched places (maybe Lily heped them, her wand was "extra good for charms"!) using the switching spell. Why else would JKR add that stuff? (info on switching spell, and Lily's wand)
-maybe they switched because they didn't trust Black.
-Lupin seems to be best friends with Harry the moment they meet, he never stares at Harry's scar.
-Lupin also seems to know what James would think. BECAUSE HE IS JAMES!!!
-do we know what house Lupin was in? He seems like he should be in Gryffindor right?
-Also how did Hagrid get the potters' vault key if they were dead and the house was ruined?
-when Harry tells Lupin about hearing his mom (or mum) and dad die, lupin doesn't seem sad, he gets "pale", why because it wasn't really his dad dying, it was Lupin!

strange right?
It is possible... ???

[Robert D]

i dont think so but that would be cool if it was james ???

[natato]

i am Sure that he is not James poTter

[harrypotterfan:)]

how do u noe tis????????
???

[H4rry_P0tter_fan]

"I'm following my sister around" "She's on top of me"

I think that it can be true but I didnt understand a few parts to what you said heart if you read this. :o :o ???

        :P

[Naurm]

From what I've seen throughout the course of the books that doesn't seem like something that JK would do. I can't explain it, it just doesn't seem likely. When Remus first saw Harry he immediatley had a fatherly or even brotherly affection for Harry because he knew his dad and mother well. Nothing JK has said has elluded to this. I suppose if this were to happen in the last book then she would keep it as tightly under the hat as possible. I do wonder if somehow Harry will be able to communicate with his dead parents or see something like their wedding in a Pensieve but I don't think any parents will be coming back.

[ChoChangHP118]

Well, i dont know if this is true.....but harry might be able to see his parents again.....because there are rumers flying everywhere that Joe might KILL harry in the seventh!!!!!!!!!!! She would do it so no one could copy here work. (As much as i wouldn't want harry to die.....I DO NOT WANT SOMEONE COPYING JOE'S WORK!!) also daniel hopes that harry WILL die....so then he can do a dying scene in the last movie!! (If they DO do a last movie!)

[harrypotterfan:)]

Joe??my friend says james potter is not alive.....is this true ???

[ChoChangHP118]

(joe is what the j stands for in j.k. rowling........when i learn things new like that i like to say them a lot to get used to it!!)
i think both harry's parents are dead because in the forth when harrys and voldemorts wands connect....harrys parents come out of the connection along with a lot of other people that are dead!

[hermionescool]

I think that James Potter is alive:

-James and Lupin switched places (maybe Lily heped them, her wand was "extra good for charms"!) using the switching spell. Why else would JKR add that stuff? (info on switching spell, and Lily's wand)
-maybe they switched because they didn't trust Black.
-Lupin seems to be best friends with Harry the moment they meet, he never stares at Harry's scar.
-Lupin also seems to know what James would think. BECAUSE HE IS JAMES!!!
-do we know what house Lupin was in? He seems like he should be in Gryffindor right?
-Also how did Hagrid get the potters' vault key if they were dead and the house was ruined?
-when Harry tells Lupin about hearing his mom (or mum) and dad die, lupin doesn't seem sad, he gets "pale", why because it wasn't really his dad dying, it was Lupin!

strange right?
It is possible... ???

ur mental that could never happen if it does i'll take it back

[HermioneFan]

Woah! I never noticed all of that! It could be him, but i'm sorta in the middle of deciding if it is him or not... ???
hermioneschool - That's mean! it's not very noce to call someone mental...  >:(