Does anyone have any comments regarding a possible theory of a relationship or something else between snape and lily potter???
jk's interview made me think that perhaps there was something with them...or one of them anyways? wat do u all think?
no idea but I did read somthing that hinted to Snape and Lily
not a chance, he was into the dark arts and she became a member of the Order, there couldnt possibly have been anything between them, they are too different.
are you sure about that
i dont think nothing happend but i do have susptions that mabby snape had a little crush on her
a litte or a big ::)
Didn't she take his side, in this one memory, when harrys father let snape dangling upside down ?
Seems to me, that Snape was on the looser side in school and his life as teacher is dedicated to his revenge.
Maybe he had a big crush on her and thereofe he hated harrys father so much.
she helped him because she was a kind person thats all
yeah...I don't think snape liked her much...he was a bit on the racist side,so...
Having to agree with Max on this one, Snape would not have liked her as she was indeed a Muggleborn.
~K~
just because she is muggleborn dosen't change the fact that there was a possable crush or more beteewn them
I THINK SNAPE HAS A LITTLE CRUSH ON LILY... maybe....and he hates james potter bacause of that....hehehehe ::) ;D
Personally, I think Snape was an idiot in school and hated Lily because she was muggle-born. He hated James cause James was a jack@ss in school.
Yeah,Why would he need more then that to hate james,honestly?Snape would have at least appreciated the defense and help he got from lily if he actually liked her.But,Instead he called her a mudblood.Thats a little harsh for someone who has a "Crush" on her.
i agree. but on the flipside, maybe he was angry at the fact that he liked her. let us not forget that snape is half muggle too...
i think that lily had the crush on snape because didn't she always stand up for him when someone was insulting him?
WOW! MAYBE SNAPE LIKED LILY. THATS THE REASON FOR HAITING JAMES!! HE WAS JEALOS ON HIM.
He may have had a little crush on snape but not a huge one like omgsh she is so freakin hott but maybe a small one. and james was a jack@ss at skool but he turned out to be okay
i don't think that James was a jack@ss!!!!! well he was to Snape in the pensive but other than that and nicking the snitch i don't think he's a bad guy at all! but maybe your right about Lily liking Snape but i don't see why snape would hate Lily if he's the "Half Blood Prince" or so he tells harry, but he's half muggle so why should he hate Lily?
what about snape being jelous of james, but the looks of things he had no friends really and james did but maybe james could see that snape liked lily and james bullied him coz of that, made things worse by starting to date lily
Snape always hated The Marauders (James, Sirius, Peter and Remus) especially James and Sirius bacause they make fun of him and stuff and that's why he hates Harry so much. Because of his dad. It says that Sirius was handsome so Snape was probably >:( because all the girls liked him and Sirius.
Quote from: Snapes_mistress on August 8, 2005, 11:43:31 PM
Does anyone have any comments regarding a possible theory of a relationship or something else between snape and lily potter???
jk's interview made me think that perhaps there was something with them...or one of them anyways? wat do u all think?
proof that they really dislike each other is key in the fifth book when harry goes into the penseive and sees snapes memory of james embarrassing him lily sticks up for snape but he calls her a mudblood so i really doubt that they had a fling ::)
Yeah a fling = No
just to put in... snape did like lily. He apologized to lily after calling her a mudblood. He called her that in humilation and fury.
But still i highly doubt that Lilly Potter and Severus Snape had a fling during their years at Hogwarts and that Lilly likes Snape. I understand that Snape liked Lilly but i think that was only a one way exchange of feelings.
yeah snape has always liked lily then turned into love
I think Lily were friend with Snape but Snape loves her and he went to the dark side & Lily dosen't like him anymore...something like that...
if youve read the 7 book you know if there is or not and i know
OKAY SNAPE DOES LIKE :-*LILLY BECAUSE HE ASKED FODY TO SPARE HER LIFE REMEMBER????????
BUT HE DIDNT CARE ABOU HARRY OR JAMES BECAUSE JAMES HUMILIATED PEOPLE WHO WERE OR AT LEAST DIDNT SEAM, AS STRONG AS HE WAS. HE JUST WANTED LILLY TO STAY ALIVE.AND IF I REMEMBER CORECTLY IN ONE OF THE thingyIEVE MINUTE THINGYSDUMBLDORE TOLD SNAPE TO KEEP AN EYE OUT FOR HARRY AND TO PROTECT HIM THAT. AND SNAPE HAD MENTIONED THE YEAR THAT HARRY WAS TO START HOWARTS THATVOLDY HAD KILLLED LILLY AND HE WAS REALY P!SSED AT VOLDY FOR NOT SPARING LILLYS LIFE LIKE HE HAD REQUESTED!
KAY
thanks for the explanation.
no prob. sometimes the way people assume things though..............
yea i dont see how anyone who read the 7th book don't know.
i know right? they shouldent post stuff that they dont know
maybe they should check the book.
majorly agreed
do you think we are nerds because we like hp? my friends think so, but i don't care!
yes i believe we r nerds but in a good way lol
let ur friend think that just because we harry pottere were nerds because she is teh nerd for not linking harry potter understand???????????????
yea you both are right. who cares anyways, they are just too stupid to understand!
lol
hehe...
yessssssssssss i right lol
thats the only time you will be right. jk
snape loved Lily and still does even though she is dead