Harry Potter Fan

Give some reasons too if you feel like it!

GOOD! There's gotta be some real reason why Dumbledore trusts him so much. There's also gotta be a reason why Snape was so reluctant to hurt Harry... We know too little about Snape, and in fictional worlds, first impressions and vague ideas are usually quite wrong.

I think he's human....
which means, he has his good points and his bad points. He's not evil, I don't think he's quite capable of that. But he's no innocent. Yes, he killed Dumbledore. Whether or not Dumbledore planned this is unknown. The way I see it, Snape had to. It was Draco's job, and Snape had taken that unbreakable vow. So it was either Dumbledore or him. Not to mention, Snape kept trying to stop Draco. Maybe he told Dumbledore about the unbreakable vow and Dumbledore told him to kill him.


Gotta say....Dumbledore is definitely dead.

Do you think Dumbledore is going to come back as a ghost?

Quote from: harrypotterfan:) on May  3, 2007, 09:14:07 AM
Do you think Dumbledore is going to come back as a ghost?

Why not, but I wouldn't want it because then he'd be stuck and he can't move on.

I think he's innocent, that was no mistake and he murdured Dumbledore, it's so sad.... :( how Snape kills him and later he will indefinitely be killed by Voldemort or one of those Death Eaters.... ::) :-X :-\

Quote from: harrypotterfan:) on May  3, 2007, 09:14:07 AM
Do you think Dumbledore is going to come back as a ghost?

Not especially. He wasn't afraid of death, and I don't think he had any unfinished bussiness that could prevent him from continuing on to the afterlife.

Thanks Ginny, I had some hope that he was going to come back.....no there is no hope......alittle hope doesn't hurt. ;) ;D

 :o
Ginny! You never really come on anymore!
And I agree with Ginny, he's only human.

Quote from: harrypotterfan:) on May  4, 2007, 04:04:48 AM
Thanks Ginny, I had some hope that he was going to come back.....no there is no hope......alittle hope doesn't hurt. ;) ;D

Oh, you won't know... Nothing's impossible... The only thing we know for sure at this point of time is that Dumbledore is definitely dead.

Quote from: Naroto Mashima on May  4, 2007, 12:23:44 PM
Ginny! You never really come on anymore!

That's true... It's great to see you back.

LOL
okay.... ;) ;D

i think snape is good....and i think it was a plan snape and dumbledore made........cuz the curse that hit dumbledore was different from all the other avada curses.....so i think dumbledore could still be alive!

Quote from: ChoChangHP118 on May  9, 2007, 07:19:27 AM
so i think dumbledore could still be alive!

Why do you keep saying that? JK Rowling has personally *confirmed* that he's dead, so if that's not final, what is?

Quote from: 0612 on May  4, 2007, 01:47:52 PM

Quote from: Naroto Mashima on May  4, 2007, 12:23:44 PM
Ginny! You never really come on anymore!

That's true... It's great to see you back.

Thanks, although I signed on every day. I just don't post unless I feel like it. I'm still in RPs when a good one comes along but I tend to stay out of the discussions because people like to argue without logic.

Quote from: 0612 on May  9, 2007, 02:12:36 PM

Quote from: ChoChangHP118 on May  9, 2007, 07:19:27 AM
so i think dumbledore could still be alive!

Why do you keep saying that? JK Rowling has personally *confirmed* that he's dead, so if that's not final, what is?

LOL...but 0612 is right, we have to face the truth... :P

Quote from: Ginny Weasly on May 10, 2007, 06:05:04 AM
I tend to stay out of the discussions because people like to argue without logic.

lolz... I know what you mean.

Hes evil and taking over all of the wizarding community

Quote from: lexiswierd5 on August 14, 2007, 08:19:31 AM
Hes evil and taking over all of the wizarding community

he's good and loves lily how can u say he's evil and i agree with ginny he's just human he doesn't like harry cause he looks and acts like his dad but he loved harry's mom and harry will always thank him for that for never hurting him really