News:

Harry Potter Fan - 100% has been online for 20 years
Please help support this site by visiting our partners www.forbiddenplanet.com for lots of cool Harry Potter Merch!
CLICK HERE!
A small percentage of each sale goes towards the upkeep of the site.

Main Menu

Can squibs see dementors?

Started by 0612, August 8, 2004, 08:47:58 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0612

In your opinion, can Squibs see dementors? Please explain your answer.

I personally think Squibs can see dementors because they, after all, have some wizarding blood. What's your opinion?

Fawkes

#1
Um.. yeah they can..Mrs. Figg saw the dementor that was attacking Harry & Dudley.

pig


0612

Do you have your own explaination about why?

pig

because they now about magic and come from a wizzerding family.

Ginny Weasly

Because old Figgy is batty! *giggles* seriously, we can't be sure if she saw them, she might have just felt them. Dumbledor might have told her to streatch the truth a bit. So who klnows, mabey we'd seriously have to ask a squib.
My motivation
An oath I've sworn to defend


My dedication
To all that I've sworn to protect
I carry out my orders
With not a regret

sweetlikepoison

yes, of course they can see them. remember in ootp when mrs. figg described them as "big and wearing cloaks"?[/color]
Official Keeper of All Things Green and/or Shiny aboard the SS Fire & Ice

Ohh...
I wanna put my tender heart in a blender,
Watch it spin around to a beautiful oblivion...
[/color]

magicball356

But didn't the book also say that Mrs.Figgs sounded like she was describing it out of a book?
I'm a magic ball...when you release me, you will be granted with a gift...to release me, go on a magic quest and find all 12 items...more explained, later..>

Ginny Weasly

She also messed up a bit in her story, seemingly like she forgot something. If you saw a dementore, don't you think it would be easy to rember? She obiously didn't. I think Dumbledore told her to say she saw them. actually, sqibs are muggles, cept they know about magic.
My motivation
An oath I've sworn to defend


My dedication
To all that I've sworn to protect
I carry out my orders
With not a regret

Lady_Luna

Yeah, it did sound like she was making it up as she went along, so maybe Squibs can't see dementors.

Fawkes

#10
I think they can see dementors... I mean they've got some magical blood in them.. :-\ And anyway Mrs. Figg might have a bad memory or something so maybe that's why she forgot what she saw.. :-X

Ginny Weasly

again, that could be true. Either way, she got Harry off the hook.
My motivation
An oath I've sworn to defend


My dedication
To all that I've sworn to protect
I carry out my orders
With not a regret

Lady_Luna

And that's always a good thing. ;D

Audrey

 Well in my opinion,some squibs can see dementors.Some live in the Maggle world as maggle so they lose some kinda sense to feel/see dementors.These squibs feel something odd when the dementors are around but can`t really tell what it is actually.It`s like there is some one who can see ghost..well what do you think?

~Harry Potter~

They would have too.  When dudly and harry was attacked, dudly who is a muggle could feel the cold and heard the voices.  That and all the lights go out and that is kinda hard to miss.
They say trust is like a mirror, you can fix it if its broke
But you can still see the crack in your reflection