News:

Harry Potter Fan - 100% has been online for 20 years
Please help support this site by visiting our partners www.forbiddenplanet.com for lots of cool Harry Potter Merch!
CLICK HERE!
A small percentage of each sale goes towards the upkeep of the site.

Main Menu

Time to bash it!!!

Started by LavyBrown, November 20, 2005, 06:31:31 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

LavyBrown

WARNING: IF YOU HAVEN'T SEEN THE MOVIE AND YOU DON'T WANT IT SPOLILED DON'T GO ANY FARTHER!!!!!



OK for all of you who have seen the movie....it's time to bash it! lol ok I think that it was much better then the 3rd one by far...but there where somethings I didn't really like at all.

I didn't like that everything was so quick and blunt. Like Cedric's death and the graveyard seen. I think the whole thing lasted 10 minutes...at most. It's suppose to be really sad but I found myself wanting to roll my eyes and sigh at how boring it was. It wasn't until Harry was crying over his dead body back at school that you got the full impact of it. And also what was with Neville giving Harry the gillyweed. Was I the only person who was saying 'Where the hell's Dobby?'


Don't do it behind the garden gate, love is blind but the neighbours ain't!
Can I get your picture? I collect nature disasters.
Whoever said nothing's impossible never tried to slam a revolving door.
I must confess, I was born at a very early age

kt1986

I was wondering where Dobby was too, but things have to be changed to make the movies work.   ::)  It was cool, but it could have been better. 

Neo

yea i was wondering about dobby and voldemort was shown as nothing more than a 10 yr old schoolyard bully trying to impress his friends by picking a fight with a 4th grader ::)
"Without a common power to keep them in check, there will be no advancement, and the life of man is poor, solitary, nasty, brutish, and short."~Thomas Hobbes

brian

umm yeah if i hadn't read the book like a million times id love the book

first of all...what ever happened to bartemus crouch's body, they just completely forget it? and like, the entire quidditch cup?


ronweazley122

I LOVED IT!Yes,There were flaws,but they blew me away.I wasn't sad at all when I read gof and ced died,Just suprised..But they ,managed to make me sad.They sure did build up cedric...and,what was up with dumbledore?"HARRRY POTTTER?!!" "DID YOU PUT YOUR NAME IN THE GOBLET?!!!!DID YOU?!!!!GRRRR!!!"I don't remember him bein' so angry...anyway,It was amazing,But,You know...They messed up  a few things...And as for dobby,Not that dissapointed he was gone....I don't think they had the money for him.They ran out.
hey, I'm back.If you want to talk to me outside of HPF, my myspace url is www.myspace.com/hawthorne_park_forever Just add me.

You're someone, who knows someone who knows someone I once kne

Em

I almost cried when harry crying over Cedric's body!... I really liked it.... me fave ;D...... (the only thing that made me really mad was all the little kids in the theater >:(....parents these day, taking kids to PG-13 movies... :P)

0612

Oh, yeah. That part was quite emotional (the guy acting Amos Diggory is talented at wailing!). As for Dobby, well, his part wasn't *too* significant, so I think missing it out was OK. As for Dumbledore strangling Harry... boy... that was nice.

And yes, what happened to Crouch's body? It's like, Harry saw it, covered his eyes and ran away! ;D

And voldemort, he isn't as scary as the book made him to be. (Those nostrils were quite funny, in fact. ;D)

ronweazley122

#7
Yeah,And the choppy style of the plot in the beginning...And was anyone else creeped out when moaning myrtle was flirting,and almost sexually harassing harry...She was TCFC....And as for Voldie...They did okay...I wasn't terrified of him,but I wouldn't want to run into him in an alley way....Although,I think I could have escaped by yelling:"ALIEN!!!!!"
hey, I'm back.If you want to talk to me outside of HPF, my myspace url is www.myspace.com/hawthorne_park_forever Just add me.

You're someone, who knows someone who knows someone I once kne

pig

 i loved the film i thought it was brillent the best so far. yes there is things that got left out or changed but thats the point this is a film an adabtation of the book evrything cant be put in.

i thought this film was much more funny there jokes evrywhere i loved the part when snape keeps bashing ron and harrys head with his book pricles or when moody turns draco into a faret and make him go down i think it was crable pants so funny


ronweazley122

agreed....I loved it....The flaws weren't bad enough to ruin it for me.
hey, I'm back.If you want to talk to me outside of HPF, my myspace url is www.myspace.com/hawthorne_park_forever Just add me.

You're someone, who knows someone who knows someone I once kne

0612

Same here! If you look at the movie alone (as in, ignore the book), the movie's still great.
And as for the Myrtle part... I guess it was funny :P (And Filch ;D)

pig

defently but wat was up with that dogy runny  :D

0612

Oh, well... The movie made him look like a fool. What with the running thing and the cannon.

jon weasley

Quote from: kt1986 on November 20, 2005, 08:46:04 AM
I was wondering where Dobby was too, but things have to be changed to make the movies work.   ::)  It was cool, but it could have been better. 
yeah i wanted to see harrys socks from dobby
7  1/2 days till the deathly hallows!!!!!!!!!!!!

0612

Oh yes... And it'll be profitable too, when they sell those socks to collectors ;D