News:

Harry Potter Fan - 100% has been online for 20 years
Please help support this site by visiting our partners www.forbiddenplanet.com for lots of cool Harry Potter Merch!
CLICK HERE!
A small percentage of each sale goes towards the upkeep of the site.

Main Menu

mistakes in the book that I have noticed!

Started by pansy, January 17, 2003, 07:18:14 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

pansy

Jean Dixon: AKA Pansy parkinson

pansy

Okay, heres the thing. In the first book when harry has been sorted and goes to sit down, it says there were now three people left to be sorted.

Thomas dean was sorted into gryfindoor
lisa Turpin was sorted into Ravenclaw
Ron weasley was sorted into gryfindoor as well

(Unless I can't count) those are the three people left aren't they.

Well, when he's talking to percy it says that harry was asking about something when Zabina Blaise was made a hufflepuff. According to the book, the three people were already sorted. If so, where did Zabina Blaise come from? :-\

Pansy
Jean Dixon: AKA Pansy parkinson

pansy

I have another mistake shown in the book:

Hermoine is just about to leave for the train to go home for christmas. I have a question? Are her parents not muggle and have not had any connection with the wizarding world until hermoine got a letter?

Well, if im not much mistake, in the book when Harry and ron are saying goodbye to her ron says "and you could ask your parents about flamel? It would be safe wouldn't it?"
Then hermoine replies "Very safe, since there both dentists"
Well, if there both dentists and muggles, then how does she expect them to know a single thing about flamel?

Pansy
Jean Dixon: AKA Pansy parkinson

.:~*Shuiliya*~:.

Hermione corrected Ron in that last one.  

But the first... WEIRD!   I've always had the impression that Blaise Zambini was a Slytherin... they also never said what gender he/she was... at least, not that I can remember!  Wasn't there sometthing about Blaise on the Quidditch team? ???
Shui~the Queen of Monkii's in the Future World
      ~One of the two brilliant... beautiful... and majestic Spelling Mages!

Be happy! :D

Gengi

*Clears throat*

• Yes, the 'three ppl left to sort' was a mistake, but hey! nobody is perfect.

QuoteWell, if im not much mistake, in the book when Harry and ron are saying goodbye to her ron says "and you could ask your parents about flamel? It would be safe wouldn't it?"
Then hermoine replies "Very safe, since there both dentists"
Well, if there both dentists and muggles, then how does she expect them to know a single thing about flamel?
• I beileve that was just a joke. Ron probably forgot Hermione was muggle born, 'cause hey! she's so smart and it's really not that important in a good friendship. :)
Her joke was basically, 'Yes, it would be very safe to ask them as they are dentists and don't know anything about the wizarding world.' ;) ^o^ ;D

• Yes Shui, you are right. Blaise Zambini was sorted in to Slytherin House. And Blaise could be a boys name, or a girls name... I've always thought of her as a girl, my self. ^^;

Her(him) on the Quidditch Team? I dunno... o.o It kinda rings a bell. >.o; A dull one at that...[/color]
*~ Sirius Black - My fugitive stud muffin! :3

Where the moon shines bright.

.:~*Shuiliya*~:.

While reading the books, I thought it was a guy... but in all the ff's I read, she's a girl, so it's changed. .. I dunno.  I thought there was something about him/her and quidditch.. *shrugs*
Shui~the Queen of Monkii's in the Future World
      ~One of the two brilliant... beautiful... and majestic Spelling Mages!

Be happy! :D

Lily_Evans


Lily_Evans


.:~*Shuiliya*~:.

Shui~the Queen of Monkii's in the Future World
      ~One of the two brilliant... beautiful... and majestic Spelling Mages!

Be happy! :D


.:~*Shuiliya*~:.

*laughs*  ha ha ha.... (<-- Just emphisizing my laughing.. ness)
Shui~the Queen of Monkii's in the Future World
      ~One of the two brilliant... beautiful... and majestic Spelling Mages!

Be happy! :D

sweetlikepoison

Official Keeper of All Things Green and/or Shiny aboard the SS Fire & Ice

Ohh...
I wanna put my tender heart in a blender,
Watch it spin around to a beautiful oblivion...
[/color]

MrsRadcliffe0480

Blaise has to be a guy because it said in the book that there are no girls on the Slytherin quidditch team (even though there were in the movie.. mistake!!!)
. ·'´)
¸.·´¸.·´¨) ¸.·*¨)
(¸.·´ (¸.·´ ¸.·´
¸.·´¸.·*·-»Amy
(¸.·

Trixie Malfoy

*~*Trixius malfoy*~*

trixie for short, do not calll me my real name!

ronweazley122

shes/hes an extra character that will never be written about again.