HE HAS TO COME BACK!

[congirl31]

yeah,Andy is hogging the book even though shes already read it.

[Zack]

hello everyone.

[AcId_BrOoZ]

hewwo!

[Zack]

*smiles at her* hi

[AcId_BrOoZ]

*smilez back*

[digital_biscuit]

Hi all

Newbie here...

But forgive me if i'm wrong, but if Sirius is dead, then ha can't be brought back.
At the end of the goblet of fire, voldemorts last spell is undone, which is the death of harrys parents, however they come back as ghosts. When hary asks dumbledore why, he sayd something like 'Even magic cannot revert death'

So however much you want him back if he is dead, then i dont think he shall be back!!!

[.:~*Shuiliya*~:.]

*hugs digital_biscuit* Thank you!

And welcome! :purpleelephant: <-- For you!  It's a purple elephant.  I give one to all newbies ;)

[Kiara Johnson]

  *Clears throat*  Sirius has gone beyond the veil, he was not ever really stated as dead.  He has been presumed dead.  Who's to say that those behind that veil are indeedy dead?  Hum?  Now, I'm just playing devils advocate here, he can be dead or not.  Do any of us really know for sure, one way or the other?  I don't think so... the only one who knows the answer to that question would be JK herself.

[.:~*Shuiliya*~:.]

Dumbly said he was dead, Remus said he was dead.

[.:~*Shuiliya*~:.]

You remember how Luna could see the thestrals?  She said it was her mother that had died.  Her mother had gone through the veil.

[MrsRadcliffe0480]

But maybe the veil is something different. Maybe it's a different kind of death that might not take your soul but maybe your mind? Hmm... or maybe I'm just reading too far into this. But it's a theory! I think there might be a way to bring him back, but like I've said before, J.K. killed him off for a reason and I don't think he's coming back.